Bill Grimsey, King of the Clone Town

Strutton GroundRetail expert Bill Grimsey has published his report this week. It’s based on facts, says Bill, proudly. But for all the facts, the report says nothing new – it’s a rehash of other people’s ideas, and is very similar to the Mary Portas High Street Review that came before it. It takes as its foundation the death of the High Street, and is based on the belief that independent shops should just give up now.

And today Bill’s been Tweeting his praise for Tesco – it’s ‘the real deal’, and ‘Tesco’s Harris + Hoole coffee shop chain has been given licensing approval for cafes. The day out at Tesco is getting better!’.

Bill’s also Tweeted about his pleasure with Primark’s increased profits, saying the ‘consumer cares not where the stuff comes from only price!’

Of course, an alternative view would be that big stores like Primark and Tesco are actually the problem. They’ve championed price over quality or fair working conditions. Tesco have used unpaid work experience placements.  And Primark are currently paying compensation to 4000 people after the Rana Plaza sweatshop collapsed in April, leaving over 1100 people dead.

Bill’s unflagging support for Tesco, Primark et al is unsurprising, from a man who’s lived his life in clone town retailers like Iceland. But the comments about Primark are something different. I’m not sure whether they’re ill-considered, or just uncaring.

In any case, maybe we should look for grassroots ways to tackle the problem, from the floorboards up not from the boardrooms down.  An alternative view would be that, with the number of independent shops increasing in the last year by over 400 stores, it’s the clone town that’s dying. There’s certainly evidence that the number of empty shops in city centre is falling, while it’s rising in shopping centres and retail parks. So that belief that the high street has a chance is not just nostalgia, Bill; it’s facts.





2 thoughts on “Bill Grimsey, King of the Clone Town

  1. I think it is certainly true that Primark and Tesco are popular, but that doesn’t mean that in general shoppers don’t care where the stuff comes from. There are lots of people who do not shop in those places (obviously, there are a lot of places even in out of town shopping centres which are not selling the cheapest possible products, etc) and there are many reasons why people do shop there.

  2. I agree with your sentiments Dan. Bill would appear to have very little grasp of place making and no understanding whatsoever of the current local government context. He seems to think that effecting change in local authorities is like flicking a switch – you, I and many others know way better than that – it’s by in large far too simplistic in its assessment and narrow in it’s scope. It also feels very quickly thrown together and lacks proper consideration of the issues…’s not very intelligent stuff. Which is a shame as his collaborators, like Jackie Sadek, should have been able to bring their experience to bear. I’m afraid this one got my back up from the first line; “High Street Policy is very much in its infancy”. No Bill it isn’t – what is in its infancy is your thinking on the subject. 5 out of 10…but I suppose anything that draws more attention to the subject is at the very least positive.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s